The Signal & Story Diagnostic

Fifty questions that unlock a business.

This is not a sales pitch and it is not a quiz. It is the same examination a good doctor gives: we look carefully, together, before anyone prescribes anything. Most owners have never been asked these questions — and the answers they pull out are the ones that change what the business is worth.

  • 4 parts · 50 questions
  • Saves as you go — resume anytime
  • Honest beats polished

How it works

Each question gives you room to think out loud, then asks for an honest self-placement — red, yellow, or green — against concrete descriptions. Where a number needs proof, we say so up front: unevidenced answers are capped, because a diagnostic built on flattery helps no one, least of all you. At the end you get your Diagnostic Map: a scored picture of the business and the one place to start.

Without JavaScript this page is a printable worksheet: nothing you type is saved and there is no score. Print it, fill it in by hand, and bring it to the call.


Before we begin

Part 1 of 4 · 5 questions

The Five Shadows

What the business hides from itself

Every business hides a few things from itself — not out of dishonesty, but because looking straight at them is uncomfortable. These five questions are where we start, because each one predicts survival, value, and everything else we will find together. Answer them honestly and the rest of this diagnostic gets much easier.

How much of this business — sales, delivery, decisions, key relationships — runs through you personally?

This is the master question. John Warrillow calls it the Hub & Spoke test: if the business can’t run without the owner, nothing else about it is transferable or sellable. We ask it first because your answer shapes everything we prescribe.

Go deeper
  • What happened the last time you took two full weeks off — honestly?
  • What is it costing you, in growth and in life, that every important decision waits for you?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What does it cost you to win a customer, and what is that customer worth over their whole relationship with you?

Unit economics is the shadow most owners have never actually computed. David Skok’s benchmark is LTV at least 3× CAC with payback well inside a year. Growth on the wrong ratio is a machine that destroys money faster the harder you push it.

Go deeper
  • If you spent $10,000 on marketing next month, do you know — not hope, know — what would come back, and when?
  • How many months does a new customer take just to pay back what it cost to win them?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Marketing spend and new-customer counts for the trailing 12 months; revenue per customer. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If your business disappeared tomorrow, how many of your customers would be genuinely upset — and how do you know?

The Sean Ellis test: real product-market fit is when 40%+ of customers say they would be “very disappointed” to lose you. This separates genuine market pull from founder hustle propping up a nice-to-have.

Go deeper
  • When did you last actually ask customers this question, rather than assume the answer?
  • Which customers would leave first — and what do they have in common?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What percentage of your revenue comes from your single biggest customer?

Past 20% from one customer, you don’t own a business — you hold a job with one boss who can fire you. Buyers discount heavily for this; more importantly, it quietly dictates every decision you make.

Go deeper
  • What would next quarter look like if that customer left with 30 days’ notice?
  • How many decisions this year were really made to keep that one customer happy?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Revenue by customer for the trailing 12 months. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If a buyer’s accountant spent a week inside your books, what would they find?

The truth shadow. If the books aren’t clean — personal expenses mixed in, revenue recognized loosely, no normalized P&L — then every other number in this diagnostic is fiction. Quality of earnings is where every sale, loan, and serious decision eventually lands.

Go deeper
  • Could you produce a clean, accrual-basis P&L for the last 24 months this week?
  • What’s in the books that you’d feel the need to explain?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Trailing 12–24 month P&L, kept current. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Part 2 of 4 · 10 questions

The Ten That Must Be Answered

Operational and financial health

Now the operational and financial vitals — the numbers and systems a healthy business knows about itself cold. If a question makes you reach for a spreadsheet you don’t have, that reach is itself the finding. Write down what you know; flag what you’d have to go look up.

After the true cost of serving them, what do you actually make on each customer?

Contribution margin is the foundation under your unit economics. Most owners know revenue per customer; far fewer know what’s left after the real cost to deliver — which is the only number that funds growth.

Go deeper
  • Which customer or job type quietly loses you money — and why do you keep taking it?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Job- or customer-level cost and margin data. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If revenue stopped today, how many months could the business keep operating at current spend?

The survival clock. Runway determines how fast any fix must produce cash — it sets the tempo of everything we’d do together.

Go deeper
  • Do you look at a cash position number weekly, or find out when something bounces?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Current cash position and monthly operating spend. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

What share of your revenue is recurring or contracted, versus one-off work you must re-sell every month?

Recurring revenue is the single biggest lever on what a business is worth — and on how well you sleep. Warrillow’s buyers pay multiples for revenue that shows up without being re-won.

Go deeper
  • If you stopped selling for 60 days, what would next month’s revenue be?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Revenue split: recurring/contracted vs one-off, trailing 12 months. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Who personally brought in your last ten customers?

The sales-side twin of the Hub & Spoke shadow. If the answer is “me, all ten,” then revenue is an extension of your calendar — and it stops when you do.

Go deeper
  • Has anyone other than you ever closed a significant sale here?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Walk through what happens between a lead appearing and money arriving. Is it written down — and do you know your close rate?

Revenue is either a system or an accident. A documented process with a known close rate can be improved, staffed, and scaled; a founder’s instinct can’t.

Go deeper
  • If you hired a salesperson Monday, what exactly would you hand them?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Pipeline/CRM export or close-rate tracking. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If a capable new hire had to deliver your core service next week, what documentation would you hand them?

Gerber’s E-Myth question. The gap between “it’s in my head” and “it’s on paper” is the gap between self-employment and a business — and it’s exactly the done-for-you promise made repeatable.

Go deeper
  • Which parts of delivery only work because a specific person remembers how?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Core delivery SOPs / process docs. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If demand doubled next month, what would break first?

Every business has one constraint that sets its ceiling. Naming it precisely is the start of every real growth plan — this answer powers your Bottleneck report directly.

Go deeper
  • Is the bottleneck a system, a person, or you — and how long has it been the same one?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Describe your exact customer — and name a kind of customer you deliberately turn away.

Drucker’s first question. Everything downstream — offer, acquisition cost, delivery, margin — depends on this being sharp. A business that serves “anyone who pays” is optimized for no one.

Go deeper
  • When did you last say no to revenue because the customer was wrong for you?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Which channel brings you your cheapest good customers, and which your most expensive — by the numbers?

This turns your unit-economics shadow into something you can act on. Averages hide the truth: one channel is usually subsidizing another, and you can’t redirect spend you haven’t measured.

Go deeper
  • If you had to double down on exactly one channel tomorrow, could you prove which one deserves it?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Per-channel spend and customer counts. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

How many customers did you lose last year — and how many actively referred someone new?

Retention is the cheapest high-signal health metric a business has: it’s a leading indicator of churn cost, and referral rate is the market grading your work in public.

Go deeper
  • Do you know why the last five customers left — from them, not from your assumption?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Part 3 of 4 · 25 questions

The Line Twenty-Five

Strategy, market, customer, offer, operations

Grounding and mission: strategy, market, customer, offer, and the operating system underneath them. These are the questions that separate a business that knows what it is from one that is improvising. Take your time — short honest answers beat long polished ones.

Beyond making you a living — why does this business exist?

Drucker again: mission is the anchor for every hard call that follows. Not a poster on a wall — the sentence that explains what you’d protect if everything else had to change.

Go deeper
  • Would your team give the same answer you just did?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What could you be best in your market at, what are you genuinely passionate about, and what drives your economic engine — and where do the three overlap?

Jim Collins’ Hedgehog Concept. Businesses drift when they chase work outside the overlap; the overlap is where compounding starts.

Go deeper
  • What work do you currently do that clearly sits outside that overlap?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Which markets, services, and customers do you deliberately NOT pursue?

Porter: strategy is choosing what not to do. The “not” list is the real test — anyone can list what they’d accept.

Go deeper
  • Name the last opportunity you declined purely on strategic scope.

Where does the business honestly sit?

What does this business look like in ten years — and what has to be true in three for that to stay possible?

EOS’s 10-Year Target and 3-Year Picture. Direction doesn’t need to be precise; it needs to be shared and real enough to plan against.

Go deeper
  • Does anyone besides you know this picture?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What are your core values — and have you ever actually hired or fired someone because of them?

Collins and EOS agree: values you’ve never enforced are decoration. The hire/fire test is what makes them real.

Go deeper
  • Which current team member would you not rehire — and what value do they violate?

Where does the business honestly sit?

In your customer’s own words — not yours — what job do they hire you to do?

Christensen’s Jobs-to-be-Done. Customers don’t buy your service; they hire an outcome. The distance between your words and theirs is usually where marketing money dies.

Go deeper
  • When did you last hear a customer describe the job unprompted — what did they say?

Where does the business honestly sit?

How big is your realistic addressable market — and is it growing or shrinking?

Ambition needs a denominator. A great operation in a shrinking pond has a ceiling no execution can fix; knowing the number tells us which levers matter.

Go deeper
  • How many ideal customers exist within your realistic reach — hundreds, thousands, more?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Who holds power over your profits — suppliers, customers, substitutes, new entrants, or rivals — and which pressure is strongest right now?

Porter’s Five Forces, in one question. Margins are set less by how hard you work than by where power sits in your industry — knowing which force squeezes you tells us where to build leverage.

Go deeper
  • What has actually compressed your prices or margins in the last two years?

Where does the business honestly sit?

If your business didn’t exist, what would your customers honestly do instead?

April Dunford’s positioning starts here. Your real competition is often “do nothing,” a spreadsheet, or a cheap generalist — and your positioning only works if it beats the actual alternative.

Go deeper
  • Is the honest alternative another provider — or doing without?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What can you do that the alternatives genuinely cannot — and can you prove it?

Dunford’s next step: differentiation only counts if it’s true, provable, and something a customer cares about. “Better service” claimed by everyone is differentiation for no one.

Go deeper
  • What proof — numbers, outcomes, artifacts — backs your biggest claim?

Where does the business honestly sit?

When a customer meets you, what category do they file you under — and is that the category you want?

Dunford: the category a buyer assumes sets the price they expect and the competitors they compare you to. Choosing your category is choosing your context.

Go deeper
  • Does the category you’re filed under cap what you can charge?

Where does the business honestly sit?

For your core offer: what’s the dream outcome, how certain is the customer of getting it, how fast does it arrive, and how much effort must they spend?

Alex Hormozi’s Value Equation — value rises with outcome and certainty, falls with delay and effort. Most offers fail on certainty and speed, not on the outcome itself.

Go deeper
  • Which of the four levers is your offer weakest on — and what would fix it?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Could you print your offer on a menu — fixed scope, fixed price, teachable delivery — or is every engagement custom?

Warrillow and Gerber converge here: a productized, teachable offer is what makes a service business scalable and sellable. Custom-everything means every sale re-invents the work.

Go deeper
  • If you productized your best work tomorrow, what would the menu item be called?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What do you promise the customer if it doesn’t work — and does that promise genuinely remove their risk?

Hormozi’s risk reversal: whoever carries the risk controls the sale. A strong guarantee is only frightening when you don’t trust your own delivery — which is itself a finding.

Go deeper
  • What stops you from offering a bold guarantee today?

Where does the business honestly sit?

How do customers show up when you personally do nothing — no posting, no calls, no networking?

The system version of the rainmaker question: demand generation that survives your vacation. If all inbound stops when you stop, marketing is a job you hold, not an asset you own.

Go deeper
  • What did your pipeline look like the last time you went quiet for a month?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Is your lead-to-close pipeline written down and tracked in a system — stages, owners, numbers?

A funnel you can see is a funnel you can fix. Untracked pipelines fail silently: leads leak at a stage nobody watches, and the loss never shows up anywhere.

Go deeper
  • At which stage do you lose the most deals — do you know, or suspect?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: CRM or pipeline export. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Could your business model be replicated 5,000 times, franchise-style — and if not, what exactly breaks?

Gerber’s franchise-prototype thought experiment. You’ll never open 5,000 units — the point is that whatever breaks in the thought experiment is already quietly limiting you at one.

Go deeper
  • What in your model depends on conditions only you enjoy — your town, your reputation, your hands?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Which five to fifteen numbers do you actually look at every week — and would they warn you of trouble before the bank account does?

The EOS Scorecard discipline: a short list of leading indicators, reviewed weekly. Owners without one discover problems weeks late, from the least forgiving metric there is — cash.

Go deeper
  • What was the last problem your numbers caught before you felt it?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: The scorecard itself, or whatever weekly numbers review exists. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

When a problem surfaces in the business, what happens to it — and do the same problems keep coming back?

EOS’s IDS: Identify, Discuss, Solve. Recurring problems are the signature of a business that manages symptoms. The discipline of killing issues at the root is learnable — and rare.

Go deeper
  • Name a problem you’ve “solved” more than twice.

Where does the business honestly sit?

Which single vendor, tool, platform, or external condition could hurt you most if it changed tomorrow?

Concentration risk isn’t only about customers. A platform algorithm change, a key supplier, one subcontractor crew — any single point of failure you don’t control is someone else holding your margin.

Go deeper
  • If that dependency broke tomorrow, what’s the plan — or is the plan “scramble”?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Is every seat in the business filled by the right person — and knowing what you know now, would you rehire everyone on the team?

The EOS/Collins people question. Most owners answer “no” privately and act on it a year too late — and pay for that year in energy, culture, and money.

Go deeper
  • Who on the team costs you more energy than they return?

Where does the business honestly sit?

On paper, does exactly one name own each major function of the business — sales, delivery, money, people?

EOS’s Accountability Chart, not an org chart: functions, not titles. When two people own a thing, no one does — and when “you” owns everything, that’s the Hub & Spoke shadow wearing a different coat.

Go deeper
  • Which function has no real owner right now — or has you as the default owner?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: The accountability or org chart, if one exists. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Who leads when you’re not in the room — and could any of them run their area for a quarter without you?

A management layer is what separates a business that scales from a founder with helpers. Buyers look for it explicitly; growth demands it sooner than most owners expect.

Go deeper
  • Who is your successor for the thing only you currently do?

Where does the business honestly sit?

If your most experienced person left on Friday, what knowledge walks out the door with them?

Undocumented knowledge is an unpriced liability — invisible until the day it costs you a customer, a process, or a season. Documentation is the cheap insurance nobody buys in time.

Go deeper
  • What’s the one process only a single human currently knows how to run?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Sample of process documentation / knowledge base. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Do your customers see themselves as clients of the company — or clients of you personally?

The bridge from grounding to transferability. Relationships owned by the founder walk out the door with the founder — which caps what the business is worth to anyone else, including future-you.

Go deeper
  • If a customer had an urgent issue and you were unreachable, who would they trust to call?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Part 4 of 4 · 10 questions

The Last Ten

Power, enterprise value, exit

The hardest questions — durable power, enterprise value, and whether this business could ever run, grow, or sell without you. Most owners have never been asked these. A red answer here is not a failure; it is the frontier. This is where good goes to great.

What structurally stops a well-funded competitor from copying your business in eighteen months?

Hamilton Helmer’s 7 Powers — the hardest strategy question there is. “We work harder” is not a moat. Real power is structural: switching costs, cornered resources, network effects, brand, scale. Most SMBs have none — naming that honestly is the first step to building one.

Go deeper
  • If a rival hired your best people and matched your prices, what would still protect you?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Your annual growth rate plus your profit margin — does the sum clear forty?

Brad Feld’s Rule of 40, adapted from SaaS: a healthy business balances growth and profitability rather than sacrificing one for the other indefinitely. Treat the threshold as directional for a services business — the discipline of knowing both numbers is the real test.

Go deeper
  • Are you deliberately trading margin for growth right now — or just losing margin?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Revenue growth and margin figures, trailing 24 months. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Do customers pay you more than they’d pay a competitor for the same work — because of your name?

Helmer counts brand as a power precisely because it’s hard: a real premium, sustained over time, that customers pay before you’ve done anything. Discounting to win work is the opposite signal.

Go deeper
  • When did you last win a deal at a higher price than a known competitor’s bid?

Where does the business honestly sit?

If you were hit by a bus tomorrow, would the business survive ninety days? Who signs, who sells, who decides?

The ultimate transferability test — more brutal than the vacation version because there’s no phone a frightened team can still call. Every answer here is also an answer about key-person risk, banking access, and legal authority.

Go deeper
  • Could anyone else access the accounts, sign a contract, and make payroll next week?

Where does the business honestly sit?

What is this business worth today — and do you know whether that’s SDE math or EBITDA math?

Enterprise-value literacy. Owner-operated businesses trade on SDE (typically ~2–3×); larger ones on EBITDA (typically ~4–8×) — and the difference between those ladders is life-changing money. Most owners have never priced their largest asset.

Go deeper
  • What single change would move you from the SDE ladder to the EBITDA ladder?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Prior-year financials sufficient to compute SDE or EBITDA. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

Is there a written growth plan a stranger could read, believe, and fund?

Buyers pay premiums for growth potential they can verify — Warrillow lists it among the top value drivers. “It’s all up here” is worth exactly nothing in diligence.

Go deeper
  • If a bank asked for your growth plan Monday, what document would you send?

Where does the business honestly sit?

If ownership changed hands tomorrow, which revenue would genuinely survive the transition?

The core exit-readiness question. Revenue tied to your face, your relationships, or your license doesn’t transfer — and a buyer prices only what transfers. This is where Shadows 1 and 5 come home to roost.

Go deeper
  • Which specific customers would a new owner lose in year one — and what % of revenue is that?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Is there any single customer, employee, or supplier you could not afford to lose?

Warrillow’s Switzerland Structure: independence on all three fronts at once. You’ve answered the customer version already — this is the enterprise-grade test across every dependency the business has.

Go deeper
  • Of the three — customer, employee, supplier — which dependency is worst, and what would replacement actually take?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Are your contracts, IP, licenses, and key agreements written, current, and assignable — would they pass diligence?

The unglamorous deal-killer. Handshake deals, IP in personal names, non-assignable contracts — none of it matters until the week it kills a sale, a loan, or a partnership. Cheap to fix now; expensive to fix under deadline.

Go deeper
  • Is anything important — domain, IP, key contract — held in your personal name rather than the company’s?

Where does the business honestly sit?

Evidence request

At your debrief we’ll ask for: Key contracts and IP/licensing documents. A green answer stays capped at yellow until it’s evidenced — that’s what makes this a diagnosis rather than an opinion.

If you knew you were selling in exactly two years, what would you change starting Monday — and why aren’t you doing it now?

Warrillow’s synthesizing question, and the one that ties this whole diagnostic together. Everything you just listed is the real to-do list — sale or no sale, those changes make the business stronger, freer, and worth more. The only wrong answer is “nothing.”

Go deeper
  • Which item on that Monday list have you known about for more than a year?

Where does the business honestly sit?


Start free

Find out exactly where you're losing time and money — in 30 minutes, free.

No pitch, no pressure. We'll pinpoint the busywork draining your week and rank the highest-payoff fixes. You walk away with a written game plan that's yours to keep — even if we never work together.

Get your free game plan

Book your assessment

30 minutes · no pitch · you keep the plan either way